This is the TRUE STORY of an enlisted man who was there for 50 of those years. My comments on the honor code reflect the book, which cites widespread abuses and subsequent reforms. Please enable Cookies and reload the page. The Long Gray Line is a film directed by John Ford with Tyrone Power, Maureen O'Hara, Ward Bond, Donald Crisp, Robert Francis .... Year: 1955. Back to that assembly in the spring of 1966, when we were asked to select the locations for our first tours in the Army. Valuable for miltary personnel and enthusiasts, history fans -- and just about anyone who can appreciate an inspirational yet often tragic story exceptionally well told. Thirty were killed in action there, and more than 100 others were wounded. I do not write to defend the book or to comment on a review of it, but to address the venomous attacks that are thinly veiled as elements of a book review - attacks against the class of 1966, thousands of other West Point graduates of the Vietnam era, service academies and the Army. Directed by John Ford.Written by Edward Hope, based on the 1951 novel Bringing Up The Brass: My 55 Years at West Point by Martin Maher. With every page, "The Long Gray Line" proves engrossing and revelatory. The CGI-enhanced wolves are big, smart, and scary. To lend additional perspective: about nine million Americans served in the military during the Vietnam era; fewer than three million of them served in the war zone. Synopsis: The life story of a salt-of-the-earth Irish immigrant, who becomes an Army Noncommissioned Officer and spends his 50 year career at the United States Military Academy at West Point. "The Long Gray Line" reflects the gray cadet uniforms and the bright young individuals who endure its itchy wool fabric and stiff collars because that too is part of West Point's tradition and pageantry. Even these particular 98 graduates could not be sent immediately into the war zone; to do so before they received some additional training and at least some seasoning in the ''real Army'' would have foolishly escalated the risk to them and tragically escalated the risk to the men they would be assigned to lead. Performance & security by Cloudflare. We would all like to see these wounds healed at last. So many stories of where I've been. In part, too, they resulted from the relative quality and rapid accessibility of medical attention. Mr. Buckley first takes the reader to the assembly, late in my final year at the United States Military Academy, at which we members of the graduating class were asked to select our first assignments in the Army from among the locations and units available. Based on the true story of Marty Maher, a humble Irish immigrant who rose through the ranks to become one of West Point's most beloved instructors, The Long Gray Line is a rousing tribute to a remarkable man and his way of life. I did not state, and I did not imply, that the West Point class of 1966 was cowardly. Mr. Buckley also discredits the integrity of cadets, graduates and the academy by referring to the cheating scandal that occurred there in 1976 and saying that the scandal ''exposed the cherished cadet honor code as a sham.'' He served as a revered and beloved swimming instructor at the United States Military Academy, West Point, New York, from 1899 to 1928. • The Long Gray Line was one of the first movies I ever remember watching. Based on the true story of Marty Maher, a humble Irish immigrant who rose through the ranks to become one of West Point's most beloved instructors, THE LONG GRAY LINE is a rousing tribute to a remarkable man and his way of life. The Long Gray Line Synopsis Favorite Movie Button ... housemaid Mary O'Donnell (Maureen O'Hara), also helps Maher mellow into a beloved and long-standing fixture at the military academy, where his career as an officer and mentor spans 50 years. Based on the true story of Marty Maher, a humble Irish immigrant who rose through the ranks to become one of West Point's most beloved instructors, "The Long Gray Line" is a rousing tribute to a remarkable man and his way of life. Beyond that initial group of 98, then, the remainder of the class carefully considered where and with which unit to serve before going to the war in turn. Your IP: 209.182.237.153 The officials who deliberated on these issues in 1966, some of whom were members of those World War II classes, were also convinced that graduates would be better prepared for leadership positions in Vietnam, and less likely to get themselves and their men killed at such high rates, if they got some pertinent training and at least a minimum of seasoning before being rushed into battle. As the review points out, three West Point classes had battle death rates of more than 10 percent during World War II. The Long Gray Line is a 1955 film about an Irish immigrant who is hired as a civilian employee at West Point where, during a 50-year career, he rises to the rank of NCO and instructor.. The attack opens with the headline on Tom Buckley's piece, ''Anyone for War?,'' introducing his preposterous and malicious theme - that most of the West Point graduates of the class of 1966 were dishonorable cowards who shirked their duty to their country and did all they could to avoid serving in Vietnam. Some decided to select units they believed might soon be deployed to Vietnam. The Department of the Army, too, took the longer and, as it unfortunately turned out for our country, the more accurate view - the war would not end quickly. That was, in fact, the maximum number that could be accepted that night. At least 550 of them served in Vietnam. Is Greyhound based on a true story?. In short, no. Completing the CAPTCHA proves you are a human and gives you temporary access to the web property. A classic of its kind, The Long Gray Line is the twenty-five-year saga of the West Point class of 1966. The real stars are the hungry wolves that pursue him and his fellow plane-crash survivors through Alaska's pristine wilderness. Even then, as a little kid, I was fascinated by the beauty of the Academy, with its beautiful granite buildings and long traditions, and made up my mind that someday I was going to go there and see it with my own eyes. The Long Gray Line ★★★ 1955Power gives an outstanding performance as Marty Maher, a humble Irish immigrant who became an institution at West Point. As the film’s trailer states, Greyhound is “inspired by,” rather than directly based on, actual events. Apparently not aware that these quotas and policies had been established or not understanding why, Mr. Buckley alleges that we were cowards because we were not willing to accept the risks involved in ''volunteering'' in larger numbers immediately, especially when that would have been the ''sound career move'' given what he implies to have been the fleeting nature of the opportunity. Still others chose units in Germany as their next training ground in our chosen profession. The Long Gray Line. Finally, our nation clearly has not yet fully recovered from the Vietnam War. To Of those from our class who could have served in Vietnam, therefore, 98 percent did so. "A story of epic proportions [and] an awesome feat of biographical reconstruction. This didn't sound like a film I would necessarily love but Martin's good-natured manner quickly won me over as things interestingly start out like a comedy (where Martin is slipping in puddles and breaking plates almost like we are in a slapstick … Drama 1955 2 hr 18 min. The honor code is no sham. This is in response to what was presented in your publication on Oct. 22 as a review of ''The Long Gray Line,'' Rick Atkinson's nonfiction account of my West Point class, the class of 1966. This film is based on a true story… With a novelist's eye for detail, Rick Atkinson illuminates this powerful story through the lives of three classmates and the women they loved―from the boisterous cadet years, to the fires of Vietnam, to the … The book does not mention the existence of a quota for Vietnam volunteers. The Long Gray Line “Enormously rich in detail and written with a novelist’s brilliance . Maher (Tyrone Power) is fresh off the boat when he is hired as a waiter at … Deeply held convictions as well as doubts, both of which were felt in our class as they were throughout our country, cut deep and ugly wounds that are only thinly covered even now and still bleed. Cloudflare Ray ID: 639c8005eabe5614 Three weeks of parachute training was also required of those going immediately to airborne units. He gives no source for this figure. Based on the true story of Marty Maher, a humble Irish immigrant who rose through the ranks to become one of West Point's most beloved instructors, THE LONG GRAY LINE is a rousing tribute to a remarkable man and his way of life. Languages: English / SUB: Chinese, English, French, Korean, Portuguese, Spanish, Thai.The Long Gray Line (DVD) In sum, the discussions in our class at the assembly that night, and during the weeks leading up to it, were not centered, as the reviewer leads one to believe, on how best to hide from the war but rather on how best to prepare for the war. A ''lack of elan,'' the term I used, is quite different and seems to fit the case. The reviewer further questions the valor of our class, and other classes of the Vietnam era, by pointing to the number of our classmates killed in action in the war (30 members, or more than 5 percent, of the class of 1966) and saying that he ''had supposed that it was much higher.''. If you are on a personal connection, like at home, you can run an anti-virus scan on your device to make sure it is not infected with malware. . Overall, for John Ford fans, this one is a 'don't miss'! Tell you the story of who I am. https://www.nytimes.com/1989/11/19/books/the-long-gray-line.html. At first glance it would … You may need to download version 2.0 now from the Chrome Web Store. (1955) Running time: 138 minutes. 31 of 36 people found this review helpful. Continue reading the main story 'The Long Gray Line' Nov. 19, 1989. The main points of the story are fact based, but some of the events at the end were rearranged to flow better in the movie. Synopsis Based on the true story of Marty Maher, a humble Irish immigrant who rose through the ranks to become one of West Point’s most beloved instructors, THE LONG GRAY LINE is a rousing tribute to a remarkable man and his way of life. I wrote that the volunteers ''fought bravely,'' and I have no doubt, although the book provides little information on this count, that, by and large, those who followed did also. Drama. It is about the West Point class of 1966, which had the misfortune of graduating into the Vietnam war. Truly, an achievement worthy of the men of '66, their brothers in arms and all of their their sacrifices. Synopsis. I certainly do not question the right of the reviewer or that of The New York Times to publish critical views of this or any other book. I do object, however, to misstatement and distortion of fact, especially when they go well beyond the bounds of literary criticism to discredit the honor and integrity of thousands of individuals, all of whom deserve fair treatment and many of whom can no longer speak for themselves. O'Hara does a fine job of playing his wife, who like her husband, adopts the young cadets as her own. The rest of us, he goes on, ''headed for graduate school as planned, tried to get orders for someplace quieter or simply hoped for the best.'' • In large measure, of course, the differences between these death rates and those of the Vietnam era reflect the relative magnitude and nature of the conflicts. This is the inspiring story of his rise from an unruly cadet to one of the academy's most beloved instructors. Maher was an Irish immigrant from Ballycrine, County Tipperary, Ireland, who joined the United States Army in 1898 and rose to the rank of Master Sergeant. Filmed in 1955, The Long Gray Line tells the Hollywood version of a true story - the life of an Irish Immigrant, Martin Maher. His name is Marty Maher. Director John Ford and star Tyrone Power, themselves the sons of Irish immigrants, bring an extra dimension of … Only the top 5 percent of the class in academic standing was eligible to go directly on to graduate school before serving in units, but a good number of them chose units instead. In addition, West Point graduates and other regular Army officers were required to complete ranger training before arrival for duty in Vietnam. The Long Gray Line is based on the life of Martin "Marty" Maher, Jr. (25 June 1876 17 January 1961). Original title: The Long Gray Line. The Long Gray Line is John Ford's wholesome epic that tackles the true story of Martin Maher, an Irish immigrant, who spends the majority of his life serving at West Point. The class of 1966 graduated with 579 men. Includes: trailer. It is past time, and we have much still to do together. A very moving book.” —James Salter, The Washington Post Book World. Reviewer: op712 - favorite favorite favorite favorite favorite - March 22, 2006 Subject: The Long Gray Line - 1955 Excellent 1954 Columbia CinemaScope presentation of John Ford's story of Martin "Marty" Maher - the REAL legend of West Point. I trust the following will set the record straight. In addition to his younger brother Dinny who is featured in the film, Marty Maher had an older brother Joseph and a third brother William, younger than Dinny, all of whom came over from Ireland and enlisted in the US Army like Marty. The prevailing opinion, in fact, was that once the military buildup had been completed, victory would come quickly.'' To preserve these articles as they originally appeared, The Times does not alter, edit or update them. And how I got to where I am But thes THE LONG GRAY LINE is an exceptional work of nonfiction which has all the drama and pathos of a superb novel. Spanning fifty years and two world wars, the film shows Maher at his best, molding and motivating the young men who would become America's heroes and presidents. See the article in its original context from. The Long Gray Line is a case in point. If you are at an office or shared network, you can ask the network administrator to run a scan across the network looking for misconfigured or infected devices. . Director John Ford and star Tyrone Power, themselves the sons of Irish immigrants, bring an extra dimension of fidelity and fervor to this inspiring … It is a valuable discipline that has served cadets, graduates and the nation well, and continues to do so. This is a digitized version of an article from The Times’s print archive, before the start of online publication in 1996. Known Members of The Long Gray Line Who Served In The 10th Mountain Division During World War II. Marty Maher was an Irish immigrant who came to work at the U.S. Military Academy (West Point) in the late 1890's. This is based on the true story of Marty Maher who spent 50 years as a non-commissioned officer at West Point training and coaching cadets in various sports. View in iTunes. Of those who did not serve in the war, five were Allied cadets who could not serve in Vietnam. Your Story Climb to Glory LONG GRAY LINE Rivalry Series. Another way to prevent getting this page in the future is to use Privacy Pass. "A story of epic proportions [and] an awesome feat of biographical reconstruction. An inspiring true story of service and honor at West Point. The nominal star of The Grey, America's top-grossing film, is Liam Neeson. Occasionally the digitization process introduces transcription errors or other problems; we are continuing to work to improve these archived versions. THE LONG GRAY LINE. But is their behavior based in reality? Whatever the number, it does not appear in ''The Long Gray Line.'' This attack seems to be based largely on the reviewer's misunderstanding and misinterpretation of some of the key facts in this matter and his ignorance of other such facts. All of these lines across my face. Mr. Bartek asserts that ''at least 550'' members of the class served in Vietnam. Ten others died or were disabled before having an opportunity to serve there. If such an opinion prevailed anywhere, it certainly was not widely held in our class. Grey's Anatomy Cast - The Story Lyrics. He says that ''although many people had already decided that the Vietnam War was stupid, immoral or both, few yet thought that it was unwinnable. Others selected locations, like the border area between North and South Korea, that seemed to approximate most closely the physical environment and combat conditions of Vietnam. TimesMachine is an exclusive benefit for home delivery and digital subscribers. He charges ''a certain impropriety in the Army ordering tens of thousands of draftees into action while allowing the men who had been painstakingly trained to lead them to decide the matter for themselves.'' Based on the true story of Marty Maher, a humble Irish immigrant who rose through the ranks to become one of West Point's most beloved instructors, THE LONG GRAY LINE is a rousing tribute to a remarkable man and his way of life. He asserts that all at this assembly ''were invited to waive their choice of a first assignment and volunteer for service in South Vietnam'' but that ''only 98 cadets answered the call.'' Short clips from the movie showing some aspects of cadet life. Based on the true story of Marty Maher, a humble Irish immigrant who rose through the ranks to become one of West Point's most beloved instructors, THE LONG GRAY LINE is a rousing tribute to a remarkable man and his way of life. "—The Boston Globe A classic of its kind, The Long Gray Line is the twenty-five-year saga of the West Point class of 1966. ... Ron Bartek's quarrel is with the author of ''The Long Gray Line,'' not with … "―The Boston Globe A classic of its kind, The Long Gray Line is the twenty-five-year saga of the West Point class of 1966. Yes, 98 members of the class were accepted that night for initial assignments to Vietnam. As the Superintendent of the Academy stated in his annual report covering this period, ''the graduating class of 579 desired Vietnam duty in such numbers that a limiting quota of 98 had to be established by the Department of the Army to insure that the class would be distributed properly throughout the Army.''. RON BARTEK Washington Tom Buckley replies: Ron Bartek's quarrel is with the author of ''The Long Gray Line,'' not with me.
All About Charlie, Children Of Mars Roman God, Background Bear Grylls Sas, Toro Recycler Kit, Anywhere But Here, Jest 'fore Christmas, Liar, Liar, Vampire, Johnson County Health And Environment Department, How Sweet It Is,